Have you been unfairly dismissed at work or subjected to unfair Labour practice?
1. In South African Labour Law an employee can be dismissed on 1 of 3 grounds namely: Misconduct, Incapacity, or operational requirements.
2. Dismissal due to misconduct – this is the most widespread form of dismissal. In this instance, the employee is alleged to have done something wrong, also known as a fault based dismissal. In other words, it is the employees fault for doing the action or omitting to act in a certain way. Examples of these transgressions would be theft, insubordination, absconding, abuse of sick leave, late coming etc.
3. Dismissal due to incapacity – this dismissal can take 2 forms – poor work performance or ill health. In the instance of poor work performance, the employee must have received training, assistance and guidance in order to learn how to complete the tasks expected of them.
4. If they are however unable to learn the task, there would be a possibility of being dismissed for incapacity due to poor work performance. Ill health is the same principle. The employee is unable to perform their tasks due to their health conditions. The employer needs to prove that they tried to assist the employee as much as possible, however, there is no duty on the employer to keep an employee that is unable to perform their tasks to the standard expected by the employer. In the case of dismissal due to incapacity, the employee will not receive warnings or have a disciplinary hearing, but rather will have consultations with the employer to assertion whether a solution can be reached. This would be a no-fault dismissal as the dismissal is not due to the conduct of the employee
5. Dismissal for operational requirements – retrenchments. This is also known as a no-fault dismissal as the employee will be dismissed due to no fault of their own. This form of dismissal is also not based on warnings and disciplinary hearings, but rather consultations. The employer will have to prove that all alternatives were considered, and that there are no other options other than dismissing the employee. Reasons for retrenchment could be economical, technological or structural.
6. In all the above forms of dismissal the employee must be given an opportunity to state their side – if that is not done, the dismissal could be procedurally unfair. When a misconduct has been done, the employer will turn to their disciplinary code for guidance as to how to handle the matter. The employee will either receive a warning – verbal, written or final – or if the transgression is serious enough, straight to a disciplinary hearing and possible dismissal. Examples of these transgressions would be theft, insubordination,absconding, abuse of sick leave etc.
7. Dismissal due to incapacity – this dismissal can take 2 forms – poor work performance or ill health. In the instance of poor work performance, the employee must have received training, assistance and guidance in order to learn how to complete the tasks expected of them. If they are however unable to learn the task, there would be a possibility of being dismissed for incapacity due to poor work performance. Ill health is the same principle. The employee is unable to perform their tasks due to their health conditions. The employer needs to show that they tried to assist the employee as much as possible, however there is no duty on the employer to keep an employee that is unable to perform their tasks to the standard expected by the employer. In the case of dismissal due to incapacity, the employee will not receive warnings or have a disciplinary hearing, but rather will have consultations with the employer to assertion whether a solution can be reached. This would be a no-fault dismissal as the dismissal is not due to the conduct of the employee.
8. Dismissal for operational requirements – retrenchments. This is also known as a no-fault dismissal as the employee will be dismissed due to no fault of their own. This form of dismissal is also not based on warnings and disciplinary hearings, but rather consultations. The employer will have to show that all alternatives were considered, and that there are no other options other than dismissing the employee. Reasons for retrenchment could be economical, technological or structural.
Unfair Labour Practice.
Section 186(2) of the Labour Relations Act (LRA) defines “Unfair labour Practice” as “any unfair act or omission that arises between an employer and an employee involving-
1. unfair conduct by the employer relating to the promotion, demotion, probation (excluding dismissals of probationers) or training of an employee or relating to the provision of benefits to an employee);
2. the unfair suspension of an employee or any other unfair disciplinary action short of dismissal in respect of an employee;
3. a failure or refusal by an employer to reinstate or re-employ a former employee in terms of any agreement; and
4. an occupational detriment, other than dismissal, in contravention of the Protected Disclosures Act, 2000 on account of the employee having made a protected disclosure defined in that Act.”
5. The word “unfair” is mentioned several times in the above definition. For example, under part (b) of the definition the section mentions “…any other unfair disciplinary action…”.
In Solidarity obo Kern vs Mudau & others (2007, 6 BLLR 566) the employee was moved from senior personnel officer to the post of committee officer. The employee alleged that he had thus been unfairly demoted. The arbitrator decided that the action of the employer did not constitute demotion. On review, the Labour Court found that the employee had in fact been demoted because the new position was lower than the old one. The Court therefore ordered the employer to pay the employee the difference between the annual salary he had been paid and the annual salary of a HR Manager.
If an a employee wants to challenge an unfair Labour practice being committed against them they need to refer a dispute with the CCMA or designated Bargaining Council.
If you have been dismissed on any of the 3 listed grounds please contact our office to assist you in challenging your unfair dismissal.
If you have been subjected to Unfair Labour Practice please contact our office to assist you in challenging the ULP.